• Audio
  • Live tv
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
Sunday, May 28, 2023
Morning News
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Home
  • News
    • Local
    • National
    • World
  • Markets
  • Economy
  • Crypto
  • Real Estate
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
    • Automotive
    • Business
    • Computer Sciences
    • Consumer & Gadgets
    • Electronics & Semiconductors
    • Energy & Green Tech
    • Engineering
    • Hi Tech & Innovation
    • Machine learning & AI
    • Security
    • Hardware
    • Internet
    • Robotics
    • Software
    • Telecom
  • Lifestyle
    • Fashion
    • Travel
    • Canadian immigration
  • App
    • audio
    • live tv
  • Home
  • News
    • Local
    • National
    • World
  • Markets
  • Economy
  • Crypto
  • Real Estate
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
    • Automotive
    • Business
    • Computer Sciences
    • Consumer & Gadgets
    • Electronics & Semiconductors
    • Energy & Green Tech
    • Engineering
    • Hi Tech & Innovation
    • Machine learning & AI
    • Security
    • Hardware
    • Internet
    • Robotics
    • Software
    • Telecom
  • Lifestyle
    • Fashion
    • Travel
    • Canadian immigration
  • App
    • audio
    • live tv
No Result
View All Result
Morning News
No Result
View All Result
Home Tech Consumer & Gadgets

What is shadowbanning? How do I know if it has happened to me, and what can I do about it?

author by author
November 3, 2022
in Consumer & Gadgets, Internet
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0 0
A A
0
0
SHARES
14
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedinReddit
What is shadowbanning? How do I know if it has happened to me, and what can I do about it?
Credit: Shutterstock

Tech platforms use recommender algorithms to control society’s key resource: attention. With these algorithms they can quietly demote or hide certain content instead of just blocking or deleting it. This opaque practice is called “shadowbanning.”

While platforms will often deny they engage in shadowbanning, there’s plenty of evidence it’s well and truly present. And it’s a problematic form of content moderation that desperately needs oversight.

What is shadowbanning?

Simply put, shadowbanning is when a platform reduces the visibility of content without alerting the user. The content may still be potentially accessed, but with conditions on how it circulates.

It may no longer appear as a recommendation, in a search result, in a news feed, or in other users’ content queues. One example would be burying a comment underneath many others.

The term “shadowbanning” first appeared in 2001, when it referred to making posts invisible to everyone except the poster in an online forum. Today’s version of it (where content is demoted through algorithms) is much more nuanced.

Shadowbans are distinct from other moderation approaches in a number of ways. They are:

  • usually algorithmically enforced
  • informal, in that they are not explicitly communicated
  • ambiguous, since they don’t decisively punish users who violate platform policies.

Which platforms shadowban content?

Platforms such as Instagram, Facebook and Twitter generally deny performing shadowbans, but typically do so by referring to the original 2001 understanding of it.

When shadowbanning has been reported, platforms have explained this away by citing technical glitches, users’ failure to create engaging content, or as a matter of chance through black-box algorithms.

That said, most platforms will admit to visibility reduction or “demotion” of content. And that’s still shadowbanning as the term is now used.

In 2018, Facebook and Instagram became the first major platforms to admit they algorithmically reduced user engagement with “borderline” content—which in Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s words included “sensationalist and provocative content.”

YouTube, Twitter, LinkedIn and TikTok have since announced similar strategies to deal with sensitive content.

In one survey of 1,006 social media users, 9.2% reported they had been shadowbanned. Of these 8.1% were on Facebook, 4.1% on Twitter, 3.8% on Instagram, 3.2% on TikTok, 1.3% on Discord, 1% on Tumblr and less than 1% on YouTube, Twitch, Reddit, NextDoor, Pinterest, Snapchat and LinkedIn.

Further evidence for shadowbanning comes from surveys, interviews, internal whistle-blowers, information leaks, investigative journalism and empirical analyses by researchers.

Why do platforms shadowban?

Experts think shadowbanning by platforms likely increased in response to criticism of big tech’s inadequate handling of misinformation. Over time moderation has become an increasingly politicized issue, and shadowbanning offers an easy way out.

The goal is to mitigate content that’s “lawful but awful.” This content trades under different names across platforms, whether it’s dubbed “borderline,” “sensitive,” “harmful,” “undesirable” or “objectionable.”

Through shadowbanning, platforms can dodge accountability and avoid outcries over “censorship.” At the same time, they still benefit financially from shadowbanned content that’s perpetually sought out.

Who gets shadowbanned?

Recent studies have found between 3% and 6.2% of sampled Twitter accounts had been shadowbanned at least once.

The research identified specific characteristics that increased the likelihood of posts or accounts being shadowbanned:

  • new accounts (less than two weeks old) with fewer followers (below 200)
  • uncivil language being used, such as negative or offensive terms
  • pictures being posted without text
  • accounts displaying bot-like behavior.

On Twitter, having a verified account (a blue checkmark) reduced the chances of being shadowbanned.

Of particular concern is evidence that shadowbanning disproportionately targets people in marginalized groups. In 2020 TikTok had to apologize for marginalizing the black community through its “Black Lives Matter” filter. In 2021, TikTok users reported that using the word “Black” in their bio page would lead to their content being flagged as “inappropriate”. And in February 2022, keywords related to the LGBTQ+ movement were found to be shadowbanned.

Overall, Black, LQBTQ+ and Republican users report more frequent and harsher content moderation across Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and TikTok.

How can you know if you’ve been shadowbanned?

Detecting shadowbanning is difficult. However, there are some ways you can try to figure out if it has happened to you:

  • rank the performance of the content in question against your “normal” engagement levels—if a certain post has greatly under-performed for no obvious reason, it may have been shadowbanned

  • ask others to use their accounts to search for your content—but keep in mind if they’re a “friend” or “follower” they may still be able to see your shadowbanned content, whereas other users may not

  • benchmark your content’s reach against content from others who have comparable engagement—for instance, a black content creator can compare their TikTok views to those of a white creator with a similar following

  • refer to shadowban detection tools available for different platforms such as Reddit (r/CommentRemovalChecker) or Twitter (hisubway).

What can users do about shadowbanning?

Shadowbans last for varying amounts of time depending on the demoted content and platform. On TikTok, they’re said to last about two weeks. If your account or content is shadowbanned, there aren’t many options to immediately reverse this.

But some strategies can help reduce the chance of it happening, as researchers have found. One is to self-censor. For instance, users may avoid ethnic identification labels such as “AsianWomen.”

Users can also experiment with external tools that estimate the likelihood of content being flagged, and then manipulate the content so it’s less likely to be picked up by algorithms. If certain terms are likely to be flagged, they’ll use phonetically similar alternatives, like “S-E-G-G-S” instead of “sex.”

Shadowbanning impairs the free exchange of ideas and excludes minorities. It can be exploited by trolls falsely flagging content. It can cause financial harm to users trying to monetise content. It can even trigger emotional distress through isolation.

As a first step, we need to demand transparency from platforms on their shadowbanning policies and enforcement. This practice has potentially severe ramifications for individuals and society. To fix it, we’ll need to scrutinize it with the thoroughness it deserves.

Provided by
The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Citation:
What is shadowbanning? How do I know if it has happened to me, and what can I do about it? (2022, November 3)
retrieved 3 November 2022
from https://techxplore.com/news/2022-11-shadowbanning.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Set of 5 Clipper-mate Pocket Combs 5" All Fine Teeth

Avalon Coconut Body Lotion, 7 Ounce, Coconut, 7 ounces, 7 oz

What is shadowbanning? How do I know if it has happened to me, and what can I do about it?
Credit: Shutterstock

Tech platforms use recommender algorithms to control society’s key resource: attention. With these algorithms they can quietly demote or hide certain content instead of just blocking or deleting it. This opaque practice is called “shadowbanning.”

While platforms will often deny they engage in shadowbanning, there’s plenty of evidence it’s well and truly present. And it’s a problematic form of content moderation that desperately needs oversight.

What is shadowbanning?

Simply put, shadowbanning is when a platform reduces the visibility of content without alerting the user. The content may still be potentially accessed, but with conditions on how it circulates.

It may no longer appear as a recommendation, in a search result, in a news feed, or in other users’ content queues. One example would be burying a comment underneath many others.

The term “shadowbanning” first appeared in 2001, when it referred to making posts invisible to everyone except the poster in an online forum. Today’s version of it (where content is demoted through algorithms) is much more nuanced.

Shadowbans are distinct from other moderation approaches in a number of ways. They are:

  • usually algorithmically enforced
  • informal, in that they are not explicitly communicated
  • ambiguous, since they don’t decisively punish users who violate platform policies.

Which platforms shadowban content?

Platforms such as Instagram, Facebook and Twitter generally deny performing shadowbans, but typically do so by referring to the original 2001 understanding of it.

When shadowbanning has been reported, platforms have explained this away by citing technical glitches, users’ failure to create engaging content, or as a matter of chance through black-box algorithms.

That said, most platforms will admit to visibility reduction or “demotion” of content. And that’s still shadowbanning as the term is now used.

In 2018, Facebook and Instagram became the first major platforms to admit they algorithmically reduced user engagement with “borderline” content—which in Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s words included “sensationalist and provocative content.”

YouTube, Twitter, LinkedIn and TikTok have since announced similar strategies to deal with sensitive content.

In one survey of 1,006 social media users, 9.2% reported they had been shadowbanned. Of these 8.1% were on Facebook, 4.1% on Twitter, 3.8% on Instagram, 3.2% on TikTok, 1.3% on Discord, 1% on Tumblr and less than 1% on YouTube, Twitch, Reddit, NextDoor, Pinterest, Snapchat and LinkedIn.

Further evidence for shadowbanning comes from surveys, interviews, internal whistle-blowers, information leaks, investigative journalism and empirical analyses by researchers.

Why do platforms shadowban?

Experts think shadowbanning by platforms likely increased in response to criticism of big tech’s inadequate handling of misinformation. Over time moderation has become an increasingly politicized issue, and shadowbanning offers an easy way out.

The goal is to mitigate content that’s “lawful but awful.” This content trades under different names across platforms, whether it’s dubbed “borderline,” “sensitive,” “harmful,” “undesirable” or “objectionable.”

Through shadowbanning, platforms can dodge accountability and avoid outcries over “censorship.” At the same time, they still benefit financially from shadowbanned content that’s perpetually sought out.

Who gets shadowbanned?

Recent studies have found between 3% and 6.2% of sampled Twitter accounts had been shadowbanned at least once.

The research identified specific characteristics that increased the likelihood of posts or accounts being shadowbanned:

  • new accounts (less than two weeks old) with fewer followers (below 200)
  • uncivil language being used, such as negative or offensive terms
  • pictures being posted without text
  • accounts displaying bot-like behavior.

On Twitter, having a verified account (a blue checkmark) reduced the chances of being shadowbanned.

Of particular concern is evidence that shadowbanning disproportionately targets people in marginalized groups. In 2020 TikTok had to apologize for marginalizing the black community through its “Black Lives Matter” filter. In 2021, TikTok users reported that using the word “Black” in their bio page would lead to their content being flagged as “inappropriate”. And in February 2022, keywords related to the LGBTQ+ movement were found to be shadowbanned.

Overall, Black, LQBTQ+ and Republican users report more frequent and harsher content moderation across Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and TikTok.

How can you know if you’ve been shadowbanned?

Detecting shadowbanning is difficult. However, there are some ways you can try to figure out if it has happened to you:

  • rank the performance of the content in question against your “normal” engagement levels—if a certain post has greatly under-performed for no obvious reason, it may have been shadowbanned

  • ask others to use their accounts to search for your content—but keep in mind if they’re a “friend” or “follower” they may still be able to see your shadowbanned content, whereas other users may not

  • benchmark your content’s reach against content from others who have comparable engagement—for instance, a black content creator can compare their TikTok views to those of a white creator with a similar following

  • refer to shadowban detection tools available for different platforms such as Reddit (r/CommentRemovalChecker) or Twitter (hisubway).

What can users do about shadowbanning?

Shadowbans last for varying amounts of time depending on the demoted content and platform. On TikTok, they’re said to last about two weeks. If your account or content is shadowbanned, there aren’t many options to immediately reverse this.

But some strategies can help reduce the chance of it happening, as researchers have found. One is to self-censor. For instance, users may avoid ethnic identification labels such as “AsianWomen.”

Users can also experiment with external tools that estimate the likelihood of content being flagged, and then manipulate the content so it’s less likely to be picked up by algorithms. If certain terms are likely to be flagged, they’ll use phonetically similar alternatives, like “S-E-G-G-S” instead of “sex.”

Shadowbanning impairs the free exchange of ideas and excludes minorities. It can be exploited by trolls falsely flagging content. It can cause financial harm to users trying to monetise content. It can even trigger emotional distress through isolation.

As a first step, we need to demand transparency from platforms on their shadowbanning policies and enforcement. This practice has potentially severe ramifications for individuals and society. To fix it, we’ll need to scrutinize it with the thoroughness it deserves.

Provided by
The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Citation:
What is shadowbanning? How do I know if it has happened to me, and what can I do about it? (2022, November 3)
retrieved 3 November 2022
from https://techxplore.com/news/2022-11-shadowbanning.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
Tags: platform
Previous Post

‘I’m a work in progress’: Pamela Anderson on restoring her B.C. home and herself

Next Post

Selena Gomez Says Taylor Swift Is Her ‘Only Friend In The Industry’ 

Related Posts

Business

Google loses bid to move DOJ’s antitrust suit to NY from Virginia

May 27, 2023
12
Consumer & Gadgets

ChatGPT can’t lie to you, but you still shouldn’t trust it, says philosopher

May 25, 2023
11
Next Post
Selena Gomez

Selena Gomez Says Taylor Swift Is Her ‘Only Friend In The Industry’ 

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

POPULAR TODAY

Canadian immigration

Canadian work experience requirement removed for engineers in Ontario

by author
May 28, 2023
0
12

Canadian work experience requirement removed for engineers in OntarioOn May 23 in Toronto, Monte McNaughton, the Ontario Minister of Labour,...

Police: Boy shoots 2 administrators at Denver high school

May 27, 2023
12

How cars ‘waste’ two thirds of their fuel

May 28, 2023
12
Egypt

Egypt unveils recently discovered ancient workshops, tombs in Saqqara necropolis

May 28, 2023
12
Alabama quarterback Bryce Young gets a jersey from NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell after being chosen by Carolina Panthers with the first overall pick during the first round of the NFL football draft, Thursday, April 27, 2023, in Kansas City, Mo. (AP Photo/Jeff Roberson)

Panthers take Bryce Young at No. 1 overall in NFL draft

May 28, 2023
12

POPULAR NEWS

Dutch government to restrict sales of processor chip tech

May 15, 2023
33
Here’s what happens to NFTs when you die: Nifty Newsletter, April 12–18

Here’s what happens to NFTs when you die: Nifty Newsletter, April 12–18

May 19, 2023
31

Loans decline after SVB failure, Fed’s Beige Book finds, and add to stress on the economy

May 19, 2023
27
Several travel industry groups said that a travel advisory for Florida issued by the NAACP could harm small businesses in the state, specifically Black-owned ones.

Travel groups say NAACP’s Florida advisory misses the mark

May 23, 2023
22
Paul Edmonds (center) with two healthcare providers from City of Hope.

How a Breakthrough Treatment Helped ‘Cure’ This Man of HIV

May 23, 2023
18

EDITOR'S PICK

Computer Sciences

Zero trust in ‘zero trust’

by author
May 4, 2023
0
12

Trust, Zero Trust, and Trust Establishment (TE). Credit: Zero Trust in Zero Trust? (2023). In May 2021, the President of...

Read more

Biden administration regulators warn AI, employee surveillance tools could ‘turbocharge’ fraud and discrimination

Washington turns to Wall Street to help rescue dying bank

Bitcoin on-chain data highlights the steps BTC is taking to exit the bear market

Tactile tattoos to make virtual worlds tangible

Morning News

Welcome to our Ads

Create ads focused on the objectives most important to your business Please contact us info@morns.ca

PBMIY 3 in 1 15W Foldable Fast Wireless Charger Stand Compatible with iPhone 13/12/11Pro/Max/XR/XS Max/X

Modern Nightstand Bedside Desk Lamp Set of 2 for Bedroom, Living Room,Office, Dorm, Gold

Backup Camera for Car HD 1080P 4.3 Inch Monitor Rear View System Reverse Cam Kit Truck SUV Minivan Easy Installation

OPI Natural Nail Base Coat, Nail Polish Base Coat, 0.5 fl oz

  • Home
  • Audio
  • Live tv
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

© 2022 Morning News - morns.ca by morns.ca.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Local
    • National
    • World
  • Markets
  • Economy
  • Crypto
  • Real Estate
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Tech
    • Automotive
    • Business
    • Computer Sciences
    • Consumer & Gadgets
    • Electronics & Semiconductors
    • Energy & Green Tech
    • Engineering
    • Hi Tech & Innovation
    • Machine learning & AI
    • Security
    • Hardware
    • Internet
    • Robotics
    • Software
    • Telecom
  • Lifestyle
    • Fashion
    • Travel
    • Canadian immigration
  • App
    • audio
    • live tv
  • Login

© 2022 Morning News - morns.ca by morns.ca.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Google
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Go to mobile version