Whenever a new season rolls around, my screen time skyrockets—not because I’m spending more time on Instagram or other social media apps. (Okay, that’s not the full truth.) Mostly, I’m scouring the internet for new fashion finds, endlessly opening new tabs and promotional emails. I often spend so much time looking out for new brands and testing emerging trends that I forget about those tried and true retailers that are always worth coming back to.

Kohl’s has always been one of those retailers for me, and every time I find myself on the site, I remember how many chic and on-trend pieces it has each season. I’ve never been known to keep a good find to myself, so of course, I did my due diligence and spread the word to my fellow editors. Editor Jasmine Fox-Suliaman and senior fashion editor Judith Jones live on opposite coasts, but they were both in the market for new fall pieces they could tailor to their starkly different climates. So they did what they do best and scoured the Kohl’s site for exclusive items that can’t be found anywhere else. Keep scrolling to see the looks that they put together, and be prepared to want to re-create them.